Lightning Strikes on WTG: the silent scapegoat

  • Home
  • Lightning Strikes on WTG: the silent scapegoat
Image

How many times has lightning strike been blamed without evidence. What’s current practice, what’s best practice and what’s realistic?

 

Crying Lightning

There’s writing on the walls. The little brother who can’t speak yet has a pen shoved into his hand and the older siblings all point at him when the parents arrive home. Lightning gets the blame for all manner of contractual disputes. Electrical fault? Lightning. Blade damage? Lightning. Grease fire? Lightning. Your wife wants a divorce? You can’t blame lightning for that, but working in wind operations certainly doesn’t help.

Little lightning gets the blame whether guilty or not. Credit: Getty images.

The eternal “God did it” scapegoat for the OEM is a great way of getting out of paying for repairs, replacements or availability guarantees. There is an insurance product for everything but reducing risk has a cost. Insurers are reluctant to pay out on force majeure unless you have irreputable proof submitted in a timely manner. All you need is comprehensive and speedy reporting from the OEM and problem solved? Right?

Unfortunately, the systems available as standard in most wind turbines are sub-optimal. This article explores the state of play today, what options are available in the market and what the future holds for those finding themselves on the receiving end of the extended middle finger of God.

The problem with lightning cards

A lot of wind turbines in the 2-3MW class were fitted with lightning cards such as the Senvion MM82/92, Siemens 2.3 and 3.6 and the Vestas V80 to V90-3. These systems use cards mounted near the weather station on the nacelle roof that store recent lightning data (sometimes only the last lightning strike) and would need to be removed and inserted into a lightning card reader. This device, that requires calibration, would then be able to read the data on the card and this could be used as part of an investigation. The trouble is that often there was only one of these devices per wind farm, and that they were often kept in the site office or warehouse. It also means arranging inspection during what is likely to be good wind conditions for power generation. The realities of running a wind farm are that this activity gets missed. Breakdowns, servicing, inspections, uptime and repair campaigns take precedent. Unless a large scorch mark or a category 5 blade failure occurs then this technology often gets neglected. It’s manual, it’s slow and you have to climb up onto the nacelle roof in stormy conditions getting buffeted around like Michael Jackson in Earth Song. What about us?

Lightning cards are often missing as they are removed to insert into the machine to take readings and not replaced. Not pictured here.

How to check that your LPS is working

Previously rope access using a Megger tester was the only way to test that your lightning protection system was functioning. A cable running between the receptor near the blade tip and a crude brush system connecting the hub to the nacelle allowed lightning to pass from the blade to the structural elements of the WTG. Now drone technology has advanced sufficiently that LPS testing of the harder to reach parts of the blade can be done by robots which can inspect and measure numerous turbines per day. A huge improvement in safety and automation from our future overlords. If all tested OK, you hope that lightning passes through the LPS and avoids the large main bearing made of metal and grease and any sensitive electrical components. Most LPS systems are unreliable at best and dangerously poor at worst, so the lightning tends to follow a route like a badly behaved dog on a lead.

Left: Lightning receptor on blade damaged, likely during a strike. Centre: Megger testing LPS straps and components. Right: Poor contact patternbetween lightning brush and rotor. Bottom: Megger test results for one blade using rope access.

How to determine whether your WTG blades have been damaged by lightning

If you have a weather alert it may tell you what sort of weather the wind farm has seen, then the SCADA system is your first port of call. Any elevated main bearing temperatures or new electrical faults may indicate the turbine has been struck by lightning and the LPS hasn’t done its job. Beyond that you may need to leave the warmth of the office for a good old-fashioned visual inspection of the blade condition using telescopic lens, binoculars or a drone, if your site is lucky enough to have one. Otherwise, you could wait for your annual drone inspections. Failing this you can fashion some pretend binoculars using your hands and laugh about how hard it is to get a purchase order approved for something that costs 8.99 from Amazon.

1 to 3% of lightning strikes cause blade damage. Windkraft journal and WGLT.

There must be a better way

If this all sounds amateurish, that’s because it is. For a small annual fee you can have a standalone system that mounts by magnet to the tower base and sends an automated email to your inbox every time your WTG is struck by lightning. This tells you the time of the strike and the amount of strikes that have hit the turbines. If you combine this with another sensor you can listen to the turbine’s blades to allow you to determine whether there has been any blade damage from the strikes, as the microphone picks any new noise from the blade surface as it passes the tower. No climbing needed and everything is accessible to you without having to consult the OEM in support of your claim.

Standalone CMS can give you cloud access to lightning strikes recorded at the turbines. Combining the sensor data with surface damage detection, this can support your damage investigation and claim.

Top Ten Reasons for Blade CMS

Different tools for managing risk depending on your contract

  • EVENT Lightning – standalone low-cost monitoring for lightning only
  • Add SURFACE – combine EVENT with acoustic monitoring to detect blade surface damage
  • Add X-weather – combine with local weather data to contextualise the severity of the lightning strike
  • ANALYZER lightning – add in a state-of-the-art lightning detection system to your tower base to enable 61400-24 standard results including polarity and magnitude

Can you reduce the cost of your insurance premiums?

Discussions with your insurer are always tedious. To alleviate this you can also request your insurers Lightning Inspection Protocol which has useful information about what they accept in the way of: strike radius, approved weather data vendors, inspection types, validity periods and how to submit reports. This might read as a list of information that you don’t have and marks the beginning of a struggle to get the information out of the OEM or your own organisation’s antiquated systems. The wind industry with all its dynamic nuance is no longer strange waters to insurers, they have 20 years’ experience in avoiding payouts and are now able to have high level technical conversations about best practice and the benefits of CMS. By proving you are an active operator, willing to invest in your assets and able to provide reliability data, it shows you are a lower risk as a customer. This can be leveraged in negotiating your premium at renewals and also allows you to better argue claims when incidents do happen.

Why the lightning problem is only going to get worse

As wind turbines increase in size, so does blade length and tip height. With an increase in size, changes in composites and blade manufacturing are needed to rise to the challenge. Whilst automated lightning detection systems are more commonplace, good quality blade condition monitoring out of the factory is less common. This means that newer untested blades will likely bring new failure modes and interactions between lightning, the LPS and the composite and sensor materials used.

Lightning damage near the receptor. So close, yet so far.

With a changing climate, weather is expected to get weirder and more violent. Storms and hurricanes are expected to increase in number and severity as they draw their energy from warmer ocean waters. As sea surface temperatures climb, storms can intensify faster and pack higher wind speeds and heavier storm surges. This means that turbines with very little lightning provision at the time of construction may see a different reality in the following 30 years of operation.

Stronger storms meat larger untested blades

The insurers will get better. With AI educating the ignorant and stealing previously company protected data at the same time, insurers are now able to infer statistics without having access to a curated data source. Whilst operators are kept out of the bathroom by the OEM the misted shower screen of reliability and technical data is being sponged down by Claude. WTG serial defects emerge more quickly, the previously data illiterate are now savvy and that data will be leveraged against you. If you have no real-world data to defend yourself unpaid claims and increased premiums are likely to increase.

What can you do to improve your lightning data?

Specify good systems or data access in your turbine supply agreements (TSA) contracts for new wind turbines. This ensures that your problem is addressed going forward on your new fleet as it is brought into operation. For WTGs in operation, there are retrofits available using low-cost standalone systems that don’t require any integration efforts or permission slips from the OEM.

With low cost and effort you can install a standalone system that will provide a notification if your wind turbine is struck by lightning, with just the turbine number and time of strike. This allows you to inspect your turbine, check your other systems and start building a potential action with the OEM or claim with the insurer. If you know something about it, you can do something about it. In the end it all comes down to actionable data.

Leave a comment